May 12, 2019 By Lisa
Daven Mathies / Digital Traits
Gannon Burgett / Digital Traits
The Canon EOS R and Panasonic Lumix S1 fashions characterize the corporate's first exams for full-frame mirrorless cameras. Every producer brings completely different expertise. Canon had already made many full-frame DSLRs, whereas the S1 was Panasonic's first full-frame digicam. Panasonic nonetheless has rather more expertise in constructing mirrorless cameras. He principally based the fashionable mirrorless period in 2008 with the Lumix G1.
So which firm made one of the best first technology digicam? Trying on the specs, the Lumix S1 stands out in some key areas, however it may be tough to find out an actual winner. The truth that the EOS R prices $ 500 much less on the time of scripting this doc makes issues much more complicated, due to a $ 300 rebate. At a complete retail worth of $ 2,300, in comparison with $ 2,500 for H1, the choice could be a bit simpler. We’ve got fully reviewed each cameras and right here is how we examine them, from autofocus efficiency to picture high quality and video capabilities.
Panasonic Lumix S1
Canon EOS R
Full-frame 24 megapixel sensor with 96MP high-resolution mode
30 megapixel full body sensor
9 frames per second (6 with AF-C)
eight frames per second (5 frames per second with steady auto focus)
1/8000 to 60 sec.
1/8000 to 30 seconds
100-51,200 (50-204,800 expanded)
100 – 40,000 (50-102 400 expanded)
AF DFD with 225-point distinction detection
Two-pixel part detection AF with as much as 5,655 factors
Stabilization of the 5-axis sensor
(None, obtainable in lots of targets)
4K / 30p, 4K / 60p with 1.5x crop, HLG (V-Log 10 bit through firmware replace)
4K / 30 with 1.7x cropping (C-Log and 10-bit output)
OLED FLE of 5.7 m factors
FLE OLED three,7m factors
three.2-inch tilt contact display screen, 2.1 m factors
three.15 inch tilt contact display screen, 2.1 m factors
1 SD, 1 XQD (CFexpress help coming quickly)
Li-ion rated for 380 photographs
Li-ion rated at 330 strokes
5.87 x four.33 x three.82 inches
5.35 x three.87 x three.32 inches
Physique solely obtainable or with 24-105mm f / four
Physique solely obtainable or with a 24-105mm f / four
$ 2,500 (MSRP, physique solely)
$ 2,300 (MSRP, physique solely)
Panasonic Lumix S1 Critiques
Touch upon Canon EOS R
A fast look on the specs and chances are you’ll assume that the Canon is available in first right here, with 30 megapixels in comparison with the Lumix 24. Admittedly, this isn’t a really large distinction, however photographers can have a bit extra room to maneuver.
Nevertheless it's removed from being a whole story. For optimum element, the Lumix S1 includes a high-resolution mode that creates a 96 MPa composite picture from eight separate exposures. That is made potential by the sensor shift stabilization system, which strikes the sensor a half-pixel width between exposures to seize extra element, scale back the chance of moiré and exceed the Bayer filter limits.
Excessive decision mode requires a tripod and a wonderfully immobile topic. Nevertheless, though it’s very best for landscapes and structure, it can’t actually be used for portraits, wildlife or sports activities.
Shot on Lumix S1
Shot on Canon EOS R
However this isn’t the one benefit of S1. Its decrease decision truly permits it to provide sharper photographs in low mild, with a local most sensitivity of 51,200 ISO, 1/three cease over EOS R, or a boosted most of 204,800, a whole cease over Canon. The target measurements of DxOMark additionally positioned the S1 over the EOS R for the dynamic vary on the ISO base. After all, the quantity of what’s perceptible in the true world is questionable and will depend on the scene, however the S1 sensor is ready to present one of the best of each worlds between sensitivity and backbone, inserting it in entrance of the Canon.
Winner: Lumix S1
Relating to steady taking pictures efficiency, Canon and Lumix are pretty homogeneous and restricted in the identical method, however the S1 has a slight benefit. With and with out steady auto focus, the S1 performs one body per second sooner than the EOS R. It could actually attain a most of 9 frames per second, or 6 with steady autofocus, whereas Canon exceeds eight frames per second or 5 with steady autofocus.
Maybe most significantly, the S1 has a bigger picture buffer that may maintain as much as 75 RAW recordsdata based mostly on our exams. The depth of the EOS R buffer is introduced at 47 RAW, though impartial exams have decided it as much as 65. Due to its high-speed XQD card, the S1 may also be sooner to jot down. these photographs from the buffer on the reminiscence card, which limits downtime between excessive pace gusts.
To be clear, no digicam will provide the kind of pace that skilled shooters want, however the S1 is probably the most succesful in steady taking pictures.
Winner: Lumix S1
Canon's Twin Pixel Autofocus (DPAF) is among the greatest autofocus applied sciences we’ve ever examined. On the EOS R, it presents greater than 5,000 particular person part detection focus factors that work collectively to make sure correct outcomes. It really works extremely properly for single or steady autofocus modes, though the processing of all these information is among the the reason why the EOS R burst price drops to five fps with focus automated continues.
Panasonic's focus know-how, Depth from Defocus (DFD), relies on distinction detection, a kind of autofocus that, though correct, is normally a lot slower than part detection. Due to clever engineering, Panasonic has discovered a technique to pace it up significantly. In most conditions, it’s only very slowly that competing part detection techniques. The S1 additionally has an superior method of recognizing the topic that means that you can observe the eyes, faces and even some animals. Nevertheless, we’ve encountered occasional issues with the main target search, which might make you miss the crucial second.
Since DFD is actually software-based, with no hardware element aside from the imaging pixels themselves, Panasonic will most likely discover methods to enhance it over time by means of firmware updates. For now, nonetheless, the EOS R has the benefit.
Winner: Canon EOS R
It's a tough class to evaluate objectively, and we at all times suggest getting your palms on a digicam before you purchase it, so far as potential. What appears proper for one individual could really feel fully completely different from one other.
Nevertheless, some design options entice high-end newbie photographers, and each are supposed for such customers. To this finish, we should conclude that the Panasonic S1 presents a extra full and extra highly effective design, with extra buttons and dials, a high-resolution digital viewfinder and two-card slots. It additionally feels more durable and higher made, though we can’t say for positive whether or not it would face up to the climate or put on higher than the Canon.
After all, all of this has a value in weight. With the battery charged, the Lumix S1 weighs greater than some skilled digital SLRs. In case your mirrorless digicam concept consists of the "Gentle" descriptor, chances are you’ll choose the Canon, which weighs solely 23.four ounces in comparison with the Lumix, virtually 39. The EOS R can also be has a single contact slider (proven above) that may be programmed. to manage completely different settings of the digicam. It's not a characteristic that everybody likes, nevertheless it's price noting. Nevertheless, if management, sturdiness and capability are what you're in search of, go for the Lumix.
Winner: Lumix S1
Whereas Canon presents optical stabilization on numerous its RF lenses, the EOS R doesn’t have picture stabilization within the physique. The Lumix S1 makes use of a 5-axis sensor offset stabilization system that, along with powering the high-resolution mode, supplies as much as 6 stops of tremor discount. It may be mixed with stabilized lenses for even higher efficiency.
Physique stabilization is one thing that Panasonic has been doing for a very long time with its Micro 4 Thirds mirrorless techniques, so that they know the know-how properly. Canon has not but produced a digicam with built-in digicam stabilization, though the corporate has introduced that it might carry this characteristic to future EOS R collection fashions. is one other level clearly within the basket of the Lumix S1.
Winner: Lumix S1
Panasonic is properly referred to as a video firm and the Lumix GH collection (constructed on the smaller Micro 4 Thirds format) continues to showcase a number of the greatest camcorders you should purchase. The Lumix S1 does not likely goal the identical viewers, however it’s nonetheless as highly effective by way of video options. Even in comparison with the Lumix S1R, costlier, it has nice benefits. It could actually take oversampled 4K / 30 sequences throughout the complete width of the sensor with no time restrict or 4K / 60 from an APS-C tradition with a time restrict of 30 minutes. It could actually additionally document 10-bit video, however solely in Hybrid Log Gamma (HLG) mode, whereas a future paid firmware replace will enable the recording of V-Log 10-bit at a time. internally and externally.
Though the EOS R was the primary Canon to obtain each a C-log and 10-bit output, the digicam is considerably restricted in different respects by way of video. To start with, the 4K is saved from a cropped space of the 1.7X sensor, truly smaller than could be an APS-C sensor. Then he suffers from a really unhealthy curler shutter, an issue that may be exacerbated by the dearth of stabilization of the picture within the physique. Though we’re actually happy with the colour high quality of the EOS R, it is vitally tough to suggest it as a video digicam, particularly when the competitors is so robust.
Winner: Lumix S1
None of those cameras broadcasts an extended battery life, however the large stack of 3050mAh S1 permits him to take some extra photographs in comparison with the EOS R, with a ranking of 380 taken from 330. This large battery is after all one of many causes S1 weighs a lot. For what it’s price, the EOS R is definitely extra environment friendly: it attracts its 330 exposures of a battery of 1 800 mAh.
This can be as a result of Panasonic engineers have realized how a lot the Lumix S1's 5.7 million dot viewfinder consumes lots, that the digicam additionally has a Dwell Save mode. Particular View View (LVF), which mimics the way in which a DSLR manages energy. On this mode, the digicam goes to sleep after some time, however leaves sure capabilities energetic, such because the EVF eye sensor and shutter launch button. The battery life is over 1000 exposures on this mode.
Winner: Lumix S1
You possibly can name this in favor of 1 or the opposite digicam, relying in your standpoint. The Lumix S1 is constructed across the Leica L mount, which already has a group of Leica lenses, however their worth could also be prohibitively costly (they’re made by Leica, in any case). As well as, Sigma has signed on to develop L-mount lenses, with 11 of their acclaimed Artwork Collection targets at present underway. Of the three Lumix S lenses at present obtainable from Panasonic, the S Professional 50mm f / 1.four can also be top-of-the-line 50mm lenses we've ever seen – after all, at $ 2,300 it must be.
Canon is in a special boat, being the one model behind its new RF mount (it additionally has a wonderful 50mm, with an excellent sooner f / 1.2 aperture, additionally at $ 2,300). Definitely, the third-party producers will commit themselves with goals for the system, however for the second, you’ve greater than a group fairly restricted (and fairly costly).
On the constructive aspect, you’ll be able to mount any Canon EF lens, that’s, these designed for the corporate's DSLRs, on the EOS R through an adapter. The lenses stay absolutely suitable and, in our exams, provide virtually an identical AF efficiency. Sure, this cancels out the smaller kind issue of the mirrorless housing, however that implies that a variety of lenses is obtainable at completely different costs.
So, the S1 at present has extra lenses that don’t want an adapter, however could also be bigger than your finances, whereas the EOS R has fewer native lenses, however extra whole lenses in the event you rely those that will be simply tailored. We are going to give this one to the Canon, as a result of the dearth of reasonably priced lenses is a recurring downside within the Lumix S collection, however when you’ve got the finances, you’ll find a fantastic glass for the S1.
Winner: Canon EOS R
Select a winner
The Lumix S1, it's virtually two cameras in a single. This can be a hybrid digicam picture / video providing wonderful efficiency in low mild due to its 24MP sensor, and an ultra-high decision digicam able to taking photographs of 96MP when the main points are too quick . It additionally has a completely attractive EVF, two reminiscence playing cards and an expertly designed management configuration, designed to face up to skilled use. Plainly the winner clear sufficient right here.
Nevertheless, the EOS R shouldn’t be with out advantages. The autofocus system is among the greatest we've ever seen and, on the time of writing this text, it was considerably cheaper than the S1. This might make it a extra precious buy; but when cash shouldn’t be an object, we should look to the Lumix.