July 12, 2019 By Lisa
Dan Baker / Digital Traits
AMD's new AMD-based Navi graphics playing cards come within the type of RX 5700 XT and RX 5700. Each playing cards are constructed on the identical GPU core, with locks on stream processors and grasp clocks. to maintain them sooner than others. To make the most of the superior efficiency of the XT and its oddly crafted cooler shroud, it’s essential to pay a $ 50 premium. Is it price it? To seek out out, we opposed the Radeon RX 5700 XT to the RX 5700 throughout a one-on-one shootout.
To see how these playing cards evaluate to Nvidia's new Tremendous Playing cards, take a look at our authentic variations of the RX 5700 XT and 5700, in addition to our head-to-head comparability with the Tremendous Nvidia RTX 2060.
The essential level of this comparability would at all times be associated to efficiency. The uncooked energy of those two playing cards is their most important differentiator. So the query is, is it price it to spend an additional $ 50 for the additional options of the 5700 XT? Let's first take a look at the specs to get an concept of what we face.
Radeon RX 5700 XT
Radeon RX 5700
Items of calculation
1 905 MHz
The primary distinction between these two playing cards lies of their variety of models of calculation. The 5700 XT has somewhat greater than 10% extra with 40, towards 36 out of 5700. This equates to the identical distinction in stream processors and needs to be a significant component in differentiating efficiency between the 2 playing cards.
One other vital issue is the clock velocity. The bottom clock is 150 MHz increased on the 5700 XT and its "gaming clock", the standard clock velocity at which you’ll anticipate sustained load, is 130 MHz increased. It will most likely not have a big affect on general efficiency, however all of this helps. The enhance frequency is way increased on the XT, however with inadequate cooling of those playing cards, we additionally don’t suppose that this velocity can be nearer to a fraction of a second close to the beginning of loading.
So far as reminiscence is anxious, the 2 playing cards are an identical with an identical configurations of GDDR6 and an an identical resultant bandwidth. The 5700 XT presents a considerable improve in TDP necessities, making it a greater candidate for aftermarket cooling, though this may occasionally recommend a better margin of overclocking on the 5700.
When it comes to how all this impacts real-world efficiency, we flip to our set of benchmarks that we did in our preliminary evaluation of each maps.
In our 3DMark Time Spy check, each playing cards work nicely. The 5700 XT has managed to remain on the similar top because the RTX 2060 Tremendous and the Radeon VII, the 5700 lagging by almost 10%. Given its 12.5% cheaper, it is a good end result.
In recreation assessments, each playing cards are performing nicely in each 1080p and 1440p, with greater than playable body charges (40 to 80 frames per second) at 4K in Fortnite, Battlefield 5, and Civilization VI. General, the RX 5700 operates at roughly 10% of the 5700 XT Index. In some circumstances it’s even nearer.
For those who're solely searching for general efficiency, the 5700 XT is clearly the most effective card, but when worth for cash is vital to you and an additional $ 50 can be extra helpful elsewhere, the 5700 holds. That is very true at 1440p, the place he manages nicely over 100 FPS in Civ VI and close to BF5 and Fortnite.
Cooling and overclocking
Dan Baker / Digital Traits
One of many greatest issues with the RX 5700 XT and 5700 is that the reference coolers are lower than the duty. Whereas some have discovered that the brand new thermo-heating paste and the added washers could make all of the distinction, the coolers prepared to be used on these playing cards usually are not nice. They’re noisy and don’t cool the GPU sufficient to stop acceleration. That's why we don’t see these playing cards taking part in on the boosted clocks that AMD claims to be able to.
Due to this and a few issues with the launch drivers, overclocking on the 5700 XT and 5700 will not be nice in the intervening time. But it surely could possibly be. With an RX 5700 XT on a customized water cooling loop with an elevated energy restrict of 95%, IgorsLab has overclocked to over 2.1 GHz on the core. This interprets into a rise in body fee of simply 11% in Shadow of the Tomb Raider.
That is an thrilling prospect for tweakers and those that are contemplating shopping for a 5700 XT third with improved cooling once they launch in August.
The 5700, however, appears to have a limiting issue past the drivers and the thermals. In a separate check, IgorsLab struck an 1800 MHz wall on the core with a 20% improve within the energy restrict. It could be a lock put in place by AMD to stop the 5700 from exceeding the efficiency of a Inventory 5700 XT. We'll have to attend for extra mature drivers to ensure, however possibly it's one thing that may be bypassed with a flash BIOS.
The main benefit of overclocking the RX 5700 in the intervening time is that it's not nice, however the potential is there. With higher cooling and a few further changes and assessments, these playing cards may be superb overclockers. If and at the moment, the 5700 may have the ability to outperform a inventory of 5700 XT if its cooling doesn’t maintain. However with a a lot bigger margin of security, no less than for the second, the 5700 XT appears to be the most effective overclocker.
Anticipate the associate playing cards
The AMD RX 5700 and 5700 XT processors are a promising model of AMD. The primary to make use of the brand new RDNA structure, these maps present a severe potential with higher cooling and extra mature drivers. Given the attractiveness of reference playing cards, it’s strongly beneficial to attend for third-party playing cards earlier than shopping for one. The wait won’t be lengthy and we are going to know far more about the actual talents of this technology in August with these associate playing cards.
But when it’s important to purchase a brand new Radeon graphics processor to make the most of FreeSync or if you wish to get the most effective worth for these two playing cards, the 5700 is the most effective of each. Its efficiency is best than prompt by its lower cost, and the restricted cooling capability supplied by the reference fan design can be much less demanding.
The 5700 XT is considerably extra highly effective and may have an even bigger margin if you happen to plan to enhance its cooling, however for now, with overclocking as it’s, the 5700 provides you extra to your cash.